If you listed those correctly, that's totalling 13-16 with you down (without factoring in the 30%/20% deciding factors). I wouldn't say that that's enough of a disparity to say it's broken. The breakdown being 50/20/30 means everything is taken into factor. I'm not going to breakdown every attack I do because I don't care enough (haha) but as numbers grow, the "what the heck" moments will disappear.