Congrats Gree!

[-H-]

First off, it's just false that you can win 90% in only you play well/smart/together. We had at least 10 wars with guilds THAT WE COULD NOT HIT ANYONE. We finished probably around 160 this war. We know how to make the most of what we have, but we never won 3 in a row and I think our record was 14-24.

Secondly, average stats and NOT, ranking is the most fair way to match. It's not perfect but it's so by far the best option it's beyond belief there is even a debate.

You guys only did 38 battles?
That could be part of the problem there.....

[-H-]

Right on, H. And congrats on another stellar performance this past weekend.

Thanks Jerusalem!

Congrats to you and your whole team as well

[JPNy]

Good point H.
Let's not forget that splinter guilds, as they have few members, need to be well organised, dedicated, determined, and ready to spend either for tough battles or between wars to remain competitive.
I for one generally play at least 50 battles and up to 60.

Yes we deserve our rewards.

[itsaklayton]

Our rewards are earned by our effort and considerable commitment: time and money, and character ability. It is what it is!

[Bohemian]

Average stats is dumb. You are then resigning all low members to get crap CP all war, and punishing people for being in small guilds that don't have huge guild bonus' unlocked.

More members = lower average stats....which means guilds in the Top 3 / Top 10 / Top 25 etc who have the most bonus' unlocked and the most members, start seeing more lower guilds.

Hugely flawed I'm afraid. There is no "perfect solution", any change GREE makes will just create new problems.

Edit : Example -

40 Member guild all with 5 mil stats
20 Member guild (perhaps it's a new guild, group of players that just got together) with 5 mil stats

Should these 2 match? The 40 members guild clearly have a huge edge...

I stick with AVERAGE.

Some reason :
1. Bring back old times when all guild near full.
2. Guild bonus will play role/worth to unlock again (increase guild members)
3. Team work put in a larger scale cause involve more peeps
4. Provide more fair n fightable battle, n give more chances for more to have fun in every rank (off course with exception if u pair with FUN,RK n SB)

[Alexius]

Back in the day you used to have time to unlock bonuses. Now with the constant events and wars you don't have the time to raise gold for upgrades. How many guilds have been stuck at the same amount of members as months ago?

[E-I]

I'd like to see Gree add a CP bonus guild upgrade.

[E-I]

I'd like to see Gree add a CP bonus guild upgrade.

And actually, a boss damage bonus would be good too. I'm sick of all there people in small 56-win guilds asking to join other guilds for events.