In all honesty I don't see how having it collect robbed buildings is an improvement. Sometimes you might wish to shift the next payout time for a building that gets hit all the time so leaving it robbed is the better option.
It's no answer to say do the others manually as the "collect all" button presumably would not disappear until all buildings are collected. For those who want the option it's best to include a collect robbed buildings on-off slider in the settings. Just not by default please.