Since we have a thread to discuss matching algorithm, I thought it made sense to start talking about impressions, experiences and input on what we thought about battle results during the war. This is the first war with a war-specific bonus and the effects of the 100 attack point units.
Oh, and try and keep it on point and not point at each other.
My impressions - on the whole, I really couldn't tell much of a difference. We were lucky to match up with some guilds from time to time where I was able to hit targets significantly higher than I am, yet it seemed that any bonuses were negligent at best.
For the first 24 hours of war, my victory screen never showed the "conquest points" displaying what I only presume was the bonus from the percentage bonus. I rarely saw results over 300, even when winning battles against players 30+ levels above. I watched guild mates hitting the same targets with roughly the same gap gathering 100 or so more cp than I would. I broke 500 once. I could likely count on one hand the times I broke 400. The bonus units really didn't seem to have any impact if they were even being applied.
As for the attack points - I'm of the same opinion that it made little to any difference. My general guideline is to seek out targets that show 20-30% lower defense than my attack. If I dared exit that range and go less than 20%, I had no more luck than I did the previous war, despite allegedly having a better chance of winning against those closer than before.
The frustrating part of this is when I initiated a ticket to find out what was going on with the missing "conquest points" line on the victory screen. The first reply I received was a math lesson on calculating compounding percentages. Thanks, I understand that, especially with the compound health regen bonuses. I sent a follow up, this time including screen shots and this time received a diatribe on the random algorithms used to determine CP, the importance of the difference in level, and to coordinate with my guild.
So, on the whole, there was SOME, but very little if any difference in my results. It's disappointing after the time and energy put in to achieve the bonuses.
Rant, compliment, share insights at will!