[Player Appreciation Month] Design An Epic Armor Voting!

They should give all the finalists the regular version of the epic winner and the winner get the plus version.

The asguardian reminds me of a paladin armor scheme from naxx

Asgardian armor is the best

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Helios_Max

It's kinda weird indeed that the Asgardian is winning... What do you think about it Lolegg?

---

Well, I didn't really know that the elements were Earth and Water until someone pointed that out, and I don't really like the style of it either. And it's quite hard to imagine how it would look like in the game, because of how it was drawn and the style of it, again. I think it would look kinda too stubby for the armour itself, but the colour would fit well. Though I voted for Steampunk Ninja (3rd place) I still think yours is very amazing indeed (along with a few other armours that I really liked)! :D And anyway, why is everyone voting for Asguardian? I know it's graphic-drawn and all cool and stylish, but the more interesting features and aspects it lacks...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lolegg4

Well, I didn't really know that the elements were Earth and Water until someone pointed that out, and I don't really like the style of it either. And it's quite hard to imagine how it would look like in the game, because of how it was drawn and the style of it, again. I think it would look kinda too stubby for the armour itself, but the colour would fit well. Though I voted for Steampunk Ninja (3rd place) I still think yours is very amazing indeed (along with a few other armours that I really liked)! :D And anyway, why is everyone voting for Asguardian? I know it's graphic-drawn and all cool and stylish, but the more interesting features and aspects it lacks...

---

I know :D The only armors that really fits well for game is the Steampunk, my Darkscale and few more. The Asgardian won more votes because it's female version :) hehehehe, that makes sense, and as well the support that it had or still have, but one thing is sure.... next time my entries will be made on Photoshop, rather and hand-made, because these guys like more the fancy colors than the details :/ And it's difficult and takes a lot of time to realize it.

We are with you Robert! :D We will try to help you on this one, for the old times bro ;)

Only reason Asgardian is up there is because the artist keeps claiming that she's "so close" with Clementine. Bias much?

Now she's winning because she's got the backing of a large alliance behind her. That's what it really comes down to. Who has the most friends since looks obviously don't matter.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by OKC Thresh

Only reason Asgardian is up there is because the artist keeps claiming that she's "so close" with Clementine. Bias much?

Now she's winning because she's got the backing of a large alliance behind her. That's what it really comes down to. Who has the most friends since looks obviously don't matter.

---

Really? Never thought of that :/

Awesome👍👍👍👍👍

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Clementine

Asgardian Wargear

Elements: Earth/Water

http://fc01.deviantart.net/fs71/i/20...in-d8a36s0.png

---

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Leogeo13

��������������������

---

What are you trying to prove out here Leo? You're proving me and the rest that everything that Thresh said is true? If it's so, then it will not make a difference.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by KnDAndy

I voted for the Darkscale Battlegear.
I'm always willing to help out a fellow Wikian/Friend :)

---

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Dark scale for the win!! I want this armor

I like the look of the Asgardian Wargear, looks very professional. However i do not agreement the suggested elements. The colors to me look more like water/air

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jonesy215

I like the look of the Asgardian Wargear, looks very professional. However i do not agreement the suggested elements. The colors to me look more like water/air

---

Lacks details

Gree should have offered gems to vote. Then this would have actually been a community vote

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sean A Roberts

Gree should have offered gems to vote. Then this would have actually been a community vote

---

Lol. But that would be good, right? Right?!

Three more votes for Darkscale to win!! If it's a tie then I wonder what will happen...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Sean A Roberts

They should give all the finalists the regular version of the epic winner and the winner get the plus version.

The asguardian reminds me of a paladin armor scheme from naxx

---

i really like your suggestion..:D

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lolegg4

Three more votes for Darkscale to win!! If it's a tie then I wonder what will happen...

---

There will be no tie Lolegg, my friends will assure that ;)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Helios_Max

There will be no tie Lolegg, my friends will assure that ;)

---

That's good to know. :p

Soo many good ones its hard to choose

Alright ladies and gentlemen, these days have been very tied between the Asgardian and Darkscale in votes. I never thought that behind this colorful artwork was a large alliance to make it win, but hear this, unknown alliance. Maybe her artwork is winning in colors but mines is winning in details, and the details are the most important aspect on a design. Another thing to mention is to those who voted rightfully for my Darkscale, Steampunk and other amazing entries. You guys are awesome as well for those who voted Asgardian without knowing of this plot. Navantgarde, I preferred more to be in a competition with your Steampunk, it really shows that you dedicated a lot of time in this one, no doubt is one of my favorite of those who posted the entries before the voting contest. And most of all, I'm very thankful of my old friends, that after so much time without seeing them, they still remember me and what I love to do <3

My vote is for Darkscale Battlegear.... This contest is gonna fail because people are voting for guild members rather than the better armor. Theres no way Asguardian should be winning...

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Helios_Max

Alright ladies and gentlemen, these days have been very tied between the Asgardian and Darkscale in votes. I never thought that behind this colorful artwork was a large alliance to make it win, but hear this, unknown alliance. Maybe her artwork is winning in colors but mines is winning in details, and the details are the most important aspect on a design. Another thing to mention is to those who voted rightfully for my Darkscale, Steampunk and other amazing entries. You guys are awesome as well for those who voted Asgardian without knowing of this plot. Navantgarde, I preferred more to be in a competition with your Steampunk, it really shows that you dedicated a lot of time in this one, no doubt is one of my favorite of those who posted the entries before the voting contest. And most of all, I'm very thankful of my old friends, that after so much time without seeing them, they still remember me and what I love to do <3

---

GAYYYY, we are not helping you :P Btw, nice drawing, you got my vote

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by tmccoy24

My vote is for Darkscale Battlegear.... This contest is gonna fail because people are voting for guild members rather than the better armor. Theres no way Asguardian should be winning...

---

I disagree, Asgardian Wargear is actually the most complete piece of artwork in the list. It looks more professional, is cleaner, and is colored in. There are several well done sketches there, but thats all they are is sketches, which are incomplete without color. GREE is not going to be able to use them as is because he will have to add color; he is not going to just put a black and white sketch into the game. The Asgardian Wargear is the only armor so complete that it can be thrown into the game as is.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jonesy215

I disagree, Asgardian Wargear is actually the most complete piece of artwork in the list. It looks more professional and is colored in. There are several well done sketches there, but thats all they are is sketches, which are incomplete without color. GREE is not going to be able to use them as is because he will have to add color; he is not going to just put a black and white sketch into the game. The Asgardian Wargear is the only armor so complete that it can actually be used as it is.

---

Complete? This must be a joke, oh... and let me tell you something... maybe the Asgardian is "complete", but its colors aren't respecting the elements she chose. Its more of a Air or Air/Water armor! Not Earth! And it lacks details. And let me remind you something, GREE is going to do the hard work on making the armor and load it into the game, not the creator. The creator only puts his sketch out here, and GREE is finishing it by removing or adding things and colors in the armor. Think twice before posting man, and of course, they aren't going to put a BLACK AND WHITE armor in the game :/

in other words youre being a jealous douche who wants his way? Good job, you've lost my vote.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by dontkilldyl

in other words youre being a jealous douche who wants his way? Good job, you've lost my vote.

---

It's not about being jealous, it's about talking in art terms and yes sometimes I really pass the line with it and give it in anger. You can't compare a finished artwork with colors and etc with a sketch that hasn't been finished. Maybe I got lazy to add the colors, but dedicating a lot of time in a single artwork is really stressful. I dunno if you can understand it, but when a next contest will appear and you'll participate and get in top 10 you will understand... some sort of it :/ Anyway, one friend of mine was right about competitions, at the beginning it's all about fun, but when you're "fighting" with a good rival for the top 1 then the things changes... and he was right about it, I can't avoid it

I vote for this one mostly for its difference from other armors in-game. I like its gold borders the most!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by jonesy215

I disagree, Asgardian Wargear is actually the most complete piece of artwork in the list. It looks more professional, is cleaner, and is colored in. There are several well done sketches there, but thats all they are is sketches, which are incomplete without color. GREE is not going to be able to use them as is because he will have to add color; he is not going to just put a black and white sketch into the game. The Asgardian Wargear is the only armor so complete that it can be thrown into the game as is.

---

Sorry mate, i have to disagree on your disagreement. Gree publicly stated that this contest is for all the KnD players who came up with any ideas with or without any artwork. that's why shifter's mantle is in top 10 eventhough it came without any artwork/sketches. the only reason it have lesser votes is it did'nt have any fancy drawings attached. i'm sure if the idea is materialize, it will look much better than most of the entries. if one single artist redraw and recreate every top 10 here and repost it for voting, will your votes is still the same? if Gree wants complete entries then they should open it only to established artist/designer then they can add a term that a fancy artwork is mandatory

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Helios_Max

It's not about being jealous, it's about talking in art terms and yes sometimes I really pass the line with it and give it in anger. You can't compare a finished artwork with colors and etc with a sketch that hasn't been finished. Maybe I got lazy to add the colors, but dedicating a lot of time in a single artwork is really stressful. I dunno if you can understand it, but when a next contest will appear and you'll participate and get in top 10 you will understand... some sort of it :/ Anyway, one friend of mine was right about competitions, at the beginning it's all about fun, but when you're "fighting" with a good rival for the top 1 then the things changes... and he was right about it, I can't avoid it

---

Just calm down, you're not helping yourself here, people are going to vote how they are going to vote, I think the Asgardian Wargear is better than your armor, which is why I voted for it, there's not some big conspiracy...

Got some suggestions to Gree for next designing epic armor contest (if any)
1) this contest should be held more often; like every month or every couple of months
2) Gree have all the rights to choose top 10 and they should redraw all the top 10's before post it for votings so that all the quality of artwork is equal and fellow forumers can vote justly
3) how about giving a normal version of the winning armor as prize for the top 10 and a + version of it to the winner instead only 65 gems so that everyone in the top 10 satisfied with the best armor they can get.

i'm sure Gree can make a very good looking armor out of every ideas but people vote based on what they see not what they could visualize from the end product of the ideas submitted.

Finally these are just my suggestions and surely Gree have all the rights to decide what they think are the best and may they come up with more intriguing contents in the near future

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ItsWil

Just calm down, you're not helping yourself here, people are going to vote how they are going to vote, I think the Asgardian Wargear is better than your armor, which is why I voted for it, there's not some big conspiracy...

---

You're right, sorry for being frenzy back there, but I haven't said nothing about the people who voted it, I just argued about the artistic details not about the voters.

Sad that the Inferno Tempest isn't doing good. :(

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by navantgarde

Got some suggestions to Gree for next designing epic armor contest (if any)
1) this contest should be held more often; like every month or every couple of months
2) Gree have all the rights to choose top 10 and they should redraw all the top 10's before post it for votings so that all the quality of artwork is equal and fellow forumers can vote justly
3) how about giving a normal version of the winning armor as prize for the top 10 and a + version of it to the winner instead only 65 gems so that everyone in the top 10 satisfied with the best armor they can get.

i'm sure Gree can make a very good looking armor out of every ideas but people vote based on what they see not what they could visualize from the end product of the ideas submitted.

Finally these are just my suggestions and surely Gree have all the rights to decide what they think are the best and may they come up with more intriguing contents in the near future

---

If they decide to be in this way, then all would win at least something good for their efforts and don't forget about the ones who posted the entries as well. They should win at least some reward for participating in the contest. Win-Win, better this way for everyone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by navantgarde

Got some suggestions to Gree for next designing epic armor contest (if any)
1) this contest should be held more often; like every month or every couple of months
2) Gree have all the rights to choose top 10 and they should redraw all the top 10's before post it for votings so that all the quality of artwork is equal and fellow forumers can vote justly
3) how about giving a normal version of the winning armor as prize for the top 10 and a + version of it to the winner instead only 65 gems so that everyone in the top 10 satisfied with the best armor they can get.

i'm sure Gree can make a very good looking armor out of every ideas but people vote based on what they see not what they could visualize from the end product of the ideas submitted.

Finally these are just my suggestions and surely Gree have all the rights to decide what they think are the best and may they come up with more intriguing contents in the near future

---

If they decide to be in this way, then all would win at least something good for their efforts and don't forget about the ones who posted the entries as well. They should win at least some reward for participating in the contest. Win-Win, better this way for everyone

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Clementine

Shifter's Mantle

Elements: Wind + Spirit

Helmet: The helmet starts right below the nose and comes up into almost a owl shaped mask with purple feathers every so often an then comes up into a feathered crown. Gold scales and a pure white metal line the outside of the mask.

Torso: A white metal torso with white feathers with purple tips in a line down the torso. The shoulders have HUGE golden metal feathers going everywhere on them and then the rest of the arm is made of pure white metal with purple tipped feathers hanging down from them.

Sword: The sword begins at the base where it has a golden handle with a light purple gem on the bottom of it. The handle goes up into a circular beginning of it with another purple gem in it. Now it goes up to a white blade and at the very end of it it has two tongs.

Shield: ( I'll make this one quick) a circular shield lined with golden feathers. In the center a purple dome with magical essence pouring out of it and surrounding the shield.

Legs: Purple tips feathers make a kilt around the waist and only goes down on the left side to the knee. The rest of the legs look like regular white leg armor except for the knees which have three gold feather on them.

---

I love this description and I would love to see it as armor. I loved the one I designed too but since it didn't make it up, this is my next favourite!

So everyone only did this to get an epic. Sad world sad biased discussion. I like the idea but when I read this thread it seems to me this should be a one time thing. Or end this poll because people are obviously encouraging freinds to subscribe etc.

On that note can I retreat my vote? I want to vote for one of the people who don't make themselves look like greedy kids. :(

Also the amount and quality of the 1-3 post votes in chat made me cringe haha. Way to go knd community

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ItsWil

Just calm down, you're not helping yourself here, people are going to vote how they are going to vote, I think the Asgardian Wargear is better than your armor, which is why I voted for it, there's not some big conspiracy...

---

I'm not too sure about there not being a big conspiracy. I get disqualified without any solid proof and one of the top 10 who happens to be winning also claims they're friends enough with Clementine to disqualify someone without any proof.

Figured I'd leave this here and let you all see what may or may not be happening in this little contest ;)
(click for larger version)
http://i.imgur.com/aVxIiXa.jpg

Who knows if someone will win and truly deserve it or if someone wins because they had the odds stacked in their favor from the very beginning...