War Idea....

[Woggy]

So with the current rewards being the top guild gets an epic+ (making them all stronger, how are they going to lose the next war when they keep getting the current epic+'s added to their armor inventory?) and the other guilds that don't do too bad but don't get anything worth keeping.....

I have an idea (Of course it won't happen because GREE don't listen to their players anyway)....

As guilds have rankings, they should have the top 1 to 50 guilds battle it out in their own war, 50 to 100 battling in their own wars and so on...

The top guild in each division gets the division prizes like normal, but the rank 50-60 guild (who will be rank 1-10 in their division, get prizes worth keeping and so on)

That way, the strong get stronger as they are now, but the weak still get to hang in there....

And the top 5 from the lower division get moved into the next division, and the bottom 5 get put down and relegated (Sort of like in the English Premier League)

Just an idea....would love to hear your thoughts

[nachomasterx]

What would stop a guild ranked #50 from tanking so they can dominate the 50-100 bracket? And how would 1-50 be decided? If a guild is number 1 in the 50-100 bracket do they move up to the top 50 bracket? If I form a new guild what bracket do I belong in?

[Lord Of The Infernal]

Guild war prize are now counter attack by chest Epic
This game is very simple no skills needed at all, just throw 600-900 gems every months opening the chest get a epic that all
My daughter a level 55 player with 1 beastmaster 1 Malstorm killing level 100+ player legendary armor easily without any skills needed o_O
Just forget about what guild war epic boss Chest is the key to winning

[deathexe]

Guild war prize are now counter attack by chest Epic
This game is very simple no skills needed at all, just throw 600-900 gems every months opening the chest get a epic that all
My daughter a level 55 player with 1 beastmaster 1 Malstorm killing level 100+ player legendary armor easily without any skills needed o_O
Just forget about what guild war epic boss Chest is the key to winning

You make it seem as though 600-900 gems gaurantee you a epic armor.

[Lord Of The Infernal]

You make it seem as though 600-900 gems gaurantee you a epic armor.

I never said is a guarantee epic at all just pure luck.
Mostly player who never come into this forums for chatting or they might not even know that a forum site they will just straight away buy chest
Which one.gains more profits for gree War Or Chest?
Sorry for bad english i am from Taiwan
And nice to know you deathaxe

[Woggy]

I'm a gem buyer and do well for myself...in fact i JUST literally opened a Aegis Of Majestic 5 minutes ago
This was mainly for the free players and to make it a bit more fair and interesting.

You'd think the top 3 guilds would get bored after a while

[EljayK]

The thing I never got about this game is the combat system in general. It's so open to pay to win, and so removing of skill. Which isn't a complaint, it just doesn't make sense to me. From the beginning it's obvious with the arena. You get set points, and possible double downs, that only come down to opening your wallet. I think it would have been better if there were rating points. You beat someone ahead of you, you get more points. Lose to someone below you, you lose more points.

Guild Wars should work the same way. Instead of a flat 50% bonus to winner, you would get a % based on the other guild's position. If you're the number 1 guild, and you beat a rank 50 guild, you only get a 10% bonus to points. But if that rank 50 guild beats you, they get 200% bonus to their points. Make it worth the fight, or the attempt to win. In the current system though I don't see it being 100% effective, or really even fair, in the given example. But if the guilds are about 20 ranks different, it would make a huge difference. I think it would liven up the 25+ ranks.

[dragonx254]

Guild war prize are now counter attack by chest Epic
This game is very simple no skills needed at all, just throw 600-900 gems every months opening the chest get a epic that all
My daughter a level 55 player with 1 beastmaster 1 Malstorm killing level 100+ player legendary armor easily without any skills needed o_O
Just forget about what guild war epic boss Chest is the key to winning
Yeah, I'm TOTALLY gonna throw $50-$100 a month on a game like this. Without even a guarantee of anything good coming out of it.

I'd rather pay my car insurance.

[Sol Invictus]

OPs criticism is valid, and I have raised it a few times before.

It's similar to how the rich get richer because it takes money to make money. In this game, the strongest become stronger.

But I suspect that is fine by GREE. By the time the same ~3 guilds win all the wars and the same ~9 people win all the tournaments and people get fed up enough with this game to move on to the next, GREE will be more than happy to take their fat purse and go home.

[Tim9870]

Kinda pointless to put gems into this war unless u are one of the top 10 guilds allready. if only the top 25 got some better rewards me and my guild mates would actually put gems into this war.