Concerns and Improvements

[Lolsies]

Hey guys!

Please list out your concerns about the game and possible improvements to the game below so that the developers can have a more organized pool of information to sift through. I will create a list below this statement as people are making suggestions and comments.

Note: 'pushed' means that the community has commented several times on this.

Concerns about KA:
1. Bugs in events/in general. Make the game smoother.

2. Late notice of events.

3. Crafting-takes too long and too expensive.

4. Lots of diamonds needed to craft epic armours.

Improvements for KA:
1. Collect all money button.

2. Input field for buying equipment.

3. Sell loot or old units.

4. Make the events more realistic (and mabye a bit easier).

5. Bring back the PD run.

6. Free gem rewards. (could base it off of WoN free gold collecting)

7. War rewards to be delivered sooner.

8. Improvements to guild management ex. creating a guild mail system.

9. Update player stats ex. contributions, last guild, etc. (pushed)

10. Don't give out chests as a reward. (pushed)

11. Improvements to rewards for increased incentive to participate in events. (pushed)

12. Improvements to the chat ex. refresh button.

13. A new event. (pushed)

14. Standings for events posted in game/on the forums. (pushed)

15. Create a dropdown menu to select different armours for different events.

[dzi11]

I dont even use elite commanders that are 10/30, in fact I get so many that I'm now just dismissing them. How about we create goals or rewards for merging 10/30's commanders?

[Jomama1]

-add army component to epic boss to reward big historic spenders
-Decent individual prizes for war - why disintivise spending?
-too many chests

for starters

[MiniBud]

Improvements for KA

Can you remove the items with expired temporary individual bonuses from our list or list them as temporary. It's hard to track what my bonus should be for some events. I show 45% bonus on EB but I don't see it when playing.

[Toddiekska]

Concerns:
Bugs in events monthly. Be proactive instead of reactive.
Customer support.
Knowing about events, when they start and what to expect ahead of time.

Updates:
Possibility to sell loot, old units, etc.
Know the smallest (1500th) unit.
Crafting reexamined, costs too much and takes too long to eventually make 1 item

Honor all of the big spenders by finding a better balance for EB.

Random is random, but being able to work toward something and achieve it would help me to decide to spend more. I have only ever made one 10/10 event.

Add to the bug list: My app crashed, I reinstalled and have had KA open for over two hours jumping to different maps. I lost my two ice towers and my finally upgrading sky temple. I sent in a ticket.
Update: it took about three hours, but I now have all of my buildings.

[Saint-BEL]

Concerns:
When you get lucky by crafting an epic piece for future upgrades (epic wizard robe, epic caster's staff for example) only way to create it, is with gems.. A very expensive gem cost whilst the demand of materials is already much higher. This is completely out of proportion and ruins the use of crafting in the first place. Get rid of the build with gems in crafting.

[JamieF]

Well, last 100 threads are about concerns and improvements..

Big concern:
- Players running away from this game due everything that happened last months! Within a 3 months my guild went from 48 to 30 players!

Concerns:
- 'Untested' updates that aren't working and we need to wait hours/days before something is been done
- Speed / lag of the game

Improvements:
- Collect all money button
- Input field for buying equipment (instead of tappinglaggg)
- Make crafting usefull
- As Toddieska said: know the smallest unit / equipment (1500)
- Skip the animation while robbing someone, it's too long and irrelevant and with the lag of the game taking toooo much time.
- Edit: something with a confirmation button placed somewhere else. Many of us have accidently deleted buildings or spend gems on useless popup units/boxes.

[Lucas HQ]

I would like to see that you guys post the war results from last wars

[Clementine]

I would like to see that you guys post the war results from last wars

My apologies that we have not been doing this recently. We should be able to start doing this again soon, as we have additional resources joining the team soon!

P.S. This is an awesome thread and I will definitely be sharing it with the Developers!

[Tigertiger55]

Please realise that crafting materials are not valuable prizes and therefore provide no motivation to play let alone succeed. You seem to feel we should treat them as pearls when they are, quite literally, rat skins.

[Totalwar]

Can you give us any idea when when we be able to upgrade craft building to level ten?please make the crafting rewards crates sightly better lately none of the of the rewards make my hero stats go up at all.

Please can we have war rewards up a lot sooner a few weeks before war start like we used to have.

Please can we have new Maps Gree.I have complete all at level 4 and most of the level 5.

[Ratma2001]

My apologies that we have not been doing this recently. We should be able to start doing this again soon, as we have additional resources joining the team soon!

P.S. This is an awesome thread and I will definitely be sharing it with the Developers!

Clementine, I have known you for quite some years now , fought along side with you grew our Alliance together, had fun and great times, but the above list speaks volumes, what we need is a firm answer on most questions ........


Updated Results from war with in 2 days ...please...it cant be that hard to post results ?
Crafting update...this needs to be addressed ....maybe Mods can answer this....please
Bring back the BD run...if possible...please...please...this would give new players a taste of real game play !!!...ohh and please.
it just pains me to bring up this but the BUGS...can we get an aerosol can to fix these...they are bad of late..or some sort of Aerogaurd type protection happening.......please
also would be nice to have a GEM reward of some sort......please.
I appreciate your time and effort in these matters and thankyou in advance
your Mate........

[Palewood]

All of the above and;
Outside of the game
- do not release things without proper testing, get it right first
- do communicate more on the forum- you can count the posts on a hand or two? I could do it myself on the train to work
- the feedback and issue resolution needs to be completely re-managed - , slow, random and often with no solution

In the game
- improve the guild management features for founders; donations, contributions, quest points etc etc player history, dates, time etc
- maintain stats when you leave and enter a guild - why back to zero
- improve the entire stats and character history that is available, people love this, it's information you have so use it - past guilds, contributions, totals of everything etc
- overall speed of the game
- buying orbs - an enter number field
- founder transfer buttons that keep the original founder in control - this is important for retrieving founder if people are sleeping, locked out, lose their device etc
- More Founder support - extra bonuses, boosts something to encourage more people to create guilds and expand the base of the game

Costs
- I think the out of things is wild - people have a budget and will stick to it but some of the costs are amazing
- a pack of rodent hides for $65 , a million or 2 of gold for $129 - do people but those product?
- I would completely re-market the costs within the game and make it more accessible in some areas, not the bread and butter but there are no value for money products

[plavine]

1) better orbs drop ( I think that was improved this time )
2) new lands with better rewards/ incentive to do them
3) new PvP quest ( win something for a certain number of fights ( and no , not a 15/25 useless item )
4) results screen after every battle & how about complete standings during the war .
5) new items to craft- remove the wood prize out if the wood box choices

[Skyraiders]

Major Concern.....

you created this thread to give the appearance of making the customer happy. hoping for my friends that this is not another farce and that you really will take into account the ideas and suggestions that are presented here so that something can be done to make the legitimate concerns people have a reality in the game.

I will tell you this will make or break you gree....people have had enough....this thread could save the game and return it to prominence ....however if this is just another way for you to deflect the real problems with the game ....it could become the straw that broke the camels back.

I for one hope you really are taking this seriously

[Shade CBD]

Something to break the monotonous circle of RB, EB, 2 Box events, Trials, building for every war cycle. It's a constant loop that has become boring

[E-I]

Major Concern.....

you created this thread to give the appearance of making the customer happy. hoping for my friends that this is not another farce and that you really will take into account the ideas and suggestions that are presented here so that something can be done to make the legitimate concerns people have a reality in the game.


^This.

Let's be honest Gree, there dozens of recent threads where players voice their concerns and make suggestions on how to improve the game. Instead of creating this pointless thread (which you likely won't read anyway), how about you just go back through the last 50 new threads and address the concerns that we have already voiced?

[E-I]

Since I know you are not going to go back and read the many threads with good, useful feedback, here is a relatively brief list of concerns:

1) Crafting sucks. Many long time players absolutely hate it.
2) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize. We want to know what our reward will be.
3) Stop giving out equipment for individual rewards. Why should I spend 5 mountains for equipment that goes straight to my army? You previously gave out units with bonuses for this level of spending.
4) PVP was much better when it was determined by army attack vs army defense (plus skill point modification). As a defender, why should your army attack stat be factored in? Why make any distinction between attack and defense then?
5) Epic Boss sucks. It used to be the best event until you based it off of equipment. Change it back.
6) If a reward has a temporary bonus, MAKE THAT VERY CLEAR before people spend gems on it.
7) You release new, buggy events haphazardly without thorough testing. And what is worse, occasionally you do that right before war.
8) Never never never have another 2 week war cycle. I cannot emphasize this enough. Although you said you would not do this again, well, we have been lied to before about this.
9) If you are going to introduce a new type of event (which is rumored), then please make sure there is ample time built into the schedule. Do NOT try to cram in a 3rd week-long event in between wars. Give us a chance to catch our breath.

[the_bob]

2) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize. We want to know what our reward will be.

1) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
2) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
3) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
4) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
5) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
6) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
7) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
8) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
9) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
10) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.

Forgot one:

11) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.

[Tigertiger55]

��^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^��
.............what the_bob said...............

[Toddiekska]

#the Bob
I laughed so hard, because it's true. My kids asked what's up, but there was no way to really explain.
👍

[[rudy]]

1) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
2) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
3) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
4) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
5) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
6) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
7) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
8) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
9) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.
10) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.

Forgot one:

11) Stop giving out chests. Nobody wants a chest as a prize.

Why, I need chests. Some people call it the boobs.

[Acadian]

Random chests are great when the new guys get a good prize, but lame when we don't. My iPhone takes a minute to open each chest, when its an item/unit you win, its instant. See the problem?
Please help us that are getting laggier and laggier. Give us a button to collect from all buildings. Give us a button to summon the mini bosses please. The time it takes to log in and randomly pop one is lame, we have jobs, cant always spend the time to randomly generate one. Not to mention out of the 5 characters I have, 3 of them are constantly out of sync and cannot even collect the dragon eggs, they keep disappearing. 2 are connected to 2 other chars, all 4 on same game center, one is by himself and still has same issue, I can't even farm for equipment or do the quests to gain any, every quest mob or 3 to 4 regular ones and it is out of sync. Please fix this issue.

[Ratma2001]

o.k , I have thought about this in depth...something new for me, but im sure most would agree with this proposal.....

Gree wishes us to spend our hard earned dollars ingame more...how do they do that....with the same old boring buy gems here and there and throw a few 20% off special every quarter and before wars...but how does this "ENTICE" the normal player ???......it doesn't really, except the Spenders !! how do you get more BANG FOR YOUR BUCK !!

o.k you may need to read twice but here is the gist of this.......
Gree need to implement RANDOM DISCOUNT CHESTS...yes more Chests...but these are different.. these have a % discount off attached to them , so they have 3-5 chests available for you to choose ONE of....each chest has a different discount % lets say 10% being the smallest and 75% being the highest .
would you buy gems if you got a 75% discount chest ??? I know I would , work out how much you save......take your 1,500 gem at $99.00 (+VAT and exchange rate) that's $24.75, but the other chests have other % discount..i.e 10% - 20% - 30% - 40% and 75% , with there basic drop rate so obviously the 75% would be a 2-4% chance to open , or just random with in the 5 chests, it should be a win win for all and entice non spenders to tickle the money tin .
maybe once a month challenge quest to receive a discount chest , this would be locked for the player and have an expiry time of say 3 days after open ? just to be fair
interested in everyones thoughts on this .

[Ryosaeba]

How about reducing some of the outrageous amounts needed to upgrade some money buildings? For example, like the Engineering Center. It costs me 9.2mil to go from L9->L10 with 60% discount. For that, I only get 20k more gold every 12 hours.

It will take at the minimum 230 days just to break even. And this is including the fact that I have to collect on the dot every 12 hours, and excluding the gold that was needed to go from L1->L9.

I understand the high requirement was needed for the quest rewards but now that the quest is over, it would be great to see some discounts to make it a little more proportional to the rest.

Edit Add: Regarding chests, if you all gonna keep the chests, maybe have quest rewards that will up the percentages of getting rare or uncommon prizes?

Crafting: It's still mostly useless right now. I see everyone using pretty much using the same gear. People said extra gear will add to your Equipment Attack. Pointless to spend so much resources just to add 10-50 to 70k+. Upgrade the Crafting Building to L10 already and let us see what we can make to increase Hero Attack.

[Totalwar]

You said that we would get another chance to reset our skill points in January please could you give us a update when this will happen thanks.

[Konan-Barbarian]

Hey guys!

Please list out your concerns about the game and possible improvements to the game below so that the developers can have a more organized pool of information to sift through. I will create a list below this statement as people are making suggestions and comments.

Concerns about KA:

Improvements for KA:

Better guild management stats and data. What is needed is like a date of last activity, average gold donation over a time period, guild leader choice of say daily, monthly, 3 months or a year. Something to help weed out the non-active players or players that quit the game without having actually quit the team. The current ranking of donations and guild points don't mean much with no reference to how long it took a player to donate that amount. Is the player with 600 points that has been there a month worth as much as the player with 600 points that did that in a week ? When you need to cut those that are useless or the weakest link, it's hard to figure out without having a team member do much record keeping and time consuming activity, that takes away from having fun. Also having useless players drags the team down. Another possibility is a counter on chat posts to monitor activity. i'm sure a few easy things can be done to make the game less of a full time job and a more fun recreational activity.

[Totalwar]

Could Gree post to say they reading this thread please.

[Valid or]

Could Gree post to say they reading this thread please.
With it being the weekend, would not expect a reply till Monday.
Can't say I ever remeber them posting on weekends.

[Vclone]

Look at this thread started in Sept 2013. Start there...
http://forums.gree.net/showthread.php?68645-Suggestions-for-GREE-on-improvements-to-KA&highlight=Vachau

[Vclone]

Another suggestion....

We have been going through the same cycle of events over and over again. Perhaps the developers can...you know... develop something new. EB, RB, trials, war is a little redundant. We could use something new and interesting. I'm not suggesting that we go back to the ltq of killing hundreds of mobs on the same map.

[Lolsies]

Whooh! You guys had a doozy!

I will add your suggestions in now.

[Toddiekska]

Whooh! You guys had a doozy!

I will add your suggestions in now.

Which of the numerous "doozies" are you referring to? A doozy implies only one.
Thanks.

[Lolsies]

Could Gree post to say they reading this thread please.

They are reading this thread, do not worry :)

[Lys]

Individual War rewards... I've seen better content in my stool. There's Zero incentive to even bother trying to place anymore, because everything is total crap.

[the_bob]

Individual War rewards... I've seen better content in my stool. There's Zero incentive to even bother trying to place anymore, because everything is total crap.

Yea. I'm currently only using health refills if we're trying to fight for a win right now. We're comfortably over rank 30 last time I looked earlier today. We aren't falling out of the bracket anytime soon and we aren't rallying for a push to 25, either, so I've just been coasting. The individual rewards for the last three war cycles have been garbage. I look at them and try to think if I'd even push to have one of the Top 3 rewards if it were at all feasible for me and I don't even think I want any of those, either. Crap rewards are crap rewards, even if they're a 50/50 boot equipment and I still have 1400 Basic Shoes. Not worth it.

[Nacon10]

What happen to the pop up screen after fighting a rival guild that has stats of battle and cumulative cps ? Did gree remove all pop screens ?

[The red Baron]

Reduce trials, they should be possible only 3-5 days each cycle.
Bring back mixed events with wins pvp, raiding special buildings and killing mobs.
And please no chests as reward

[Konan-Barbarian]

#1 Better 'live' guild chat.
It takes too much time to hit menu+guild+chat, then red x, then guild+chat again (to refresh) and so on around in circles. Could there be a live 'push' type chat so whenever a guild member posts, the post automatically shows up without us having to exit and restart chat to do a refresh. (your guild only, not the entire universe). Better even would be to have it on the main page, in a smaller form to preview, but one could tap on it to bring up a larger chat window, to comment. then it could be downsized again. We have some guild members that never chat. Either they are non-talkative or don't even know it is there. (Note: add same to CC and MW).

#2 Minor cosmetic fix
Make the player's name box, in lower right corner smaller. Mine says "Xxxxx's Kingdom" and then a black area next to it, just wasting screen space. It does downsize some if I visit someone else with a shorter name, but there still is extra back space.

[the_bob]

Could there be a live 'push' type chat

No, because Gree doesn't know anything about data limits. Ask the people who went over their data usage in just a couple of days because of KA and got charged a shıt ton of money by their cell carrier. It happens a lot. There needs to simply be a Refresh button on the Chat page.

[phopjon]

-Collect all button like in CC.
-More frequent EB encounters

Since the trials started I've basically moved to camper mode, so all I really want are things that mean I can play the game LESS. Which is probably all you need to know about the game.

[Rapture claws]

Why do you have to charge DIAMONDS for old building that came up again, Alot of people on a lower lvl that I know were raiding saving money for tree forts, you just put them out of reach to the regular person, why not just let us buy the original 3 with money like everyone else did, then diamond the extra one(I probely would have bought diamonds for the extra one),I and many others cant do it on 4. this just does not make since to me. Im on my last inch of string with this game, I bet you guys loose alot of people over this..........

[Totalwar]

They are reading this thread, do not worry :)

Your saying they reading what been said but when do we get some feed back?

[Totalwar]

Why do you have to charge DIAMONDS for old building that came up again, Alot of people on a lower lvl that I know were raiding saving money for tree forts, you just put them out of reach to the regular person, why not just let us buy the original 3 with money like everyone else did, then diamond the extra one(I probely would have bought diamonds for the extra one),I and many others cant do it on 4. this just does not make since to me. Im on my last inch of string with this game, I bet you guys loose alot of people over this..........

This only lasts a few weeks then everything will get back to normal buy building for gold.theses gem building are extra building that we would not normally get.you can alway get gems though Tapjoy just save them up if this comes up again I sure it will.

[Konan-Barbarian]

No, because Gree doesn't know anything about data limits. Ask the people who went over their data usage in just a couple of days because of KA and got charged a shıt ton of money by their cell carrier. It happens a lot. There needs to simply be a Refresh button on the Chat page.

OK, But a simple button could have a player selectable option, auto/manual. Those that do not have limits because we are on wifi can use auto.

[Konan-Barbarian]

New building construction time multiple bonus do not work when 2 different ones.
-
My building construction (new construction, NOT upgrades) says 6%.
I have 2 units with bonuses of 4% and 2%.
-
So here's the math
Start at 24 hours. 24 x 60 = 1440 minutes
1440 minutes less 4% -57.6 is 1382.4 minutes or 23.04 hours or 23 hours 2 minutes 24 seconds
1382.4 minutes less 2% -27.648 is 1354.75 minutes or 22 hours 34 minutes 45 seconds
-
the game timer of the building starts at 22:59:XX somewhere about 40-48 seconds, sorry I can't check it that quickly after starting construction.
-
So where's the 2% ?
-
They do subtract something like 2.7648 minutes, not 27.648 minutes
-
They are taking about 0.02% for the second bonus !
-
See the error ?
-
I have reported this before and get a form letter response lesson on how to do the math, yet the cs people can't read my math and see that is what the are telling me and that the games result does not match up to the math.

[the_bob]

Something with building time and upgrade time went wrong recently. Same with upgrade cost reduction. The Sky Temple was the first building that didn't match up to calculations in my spreadsheet that have worked for every building.

That in itself isn't unprecedented. The payouts of LTB buildings changed after the Brewhouse. Payouts after that used a slightly different formula. I can tell you that this is not what's happened with the Sky Temple and after. Looking at the numbers the way they are now, I can tell you that some cost bonus calculation has gone belly up somewhere. The formula has stayed the same, but the bonuses aren't being applied correctly.

[E-I]

They are reading this thread, do not worry :)

And are they going to incorporate any of these suggestions? You have a lot of people unhappy with the state of the game, and even more who are unhappy with the lack of communication from Gree. Is this going to change?

Chances anyone from Gree responds: 0%

[DragCro]

Clementine, I have known you for quite some years now , fought along side with you grew our Alliance together, had fun and great times, but the above list speaks volumes, what we need is a firm answer on most questions ........


Updated Results from war with in 2 days ...please...it cant be that hard to post results ?
Crafting update...this needs to be addressed ....maybe Mods can answer this....please
Bring back the BD run...if possible...please...please...this would give new players a taste of real game play !!!...ohh and please.
it just pains me to bring up this but the BUGS...can we get an aerosol can to fix these...they are bad of late..or some sort of Aerogaurd type protection happening.......please
also would be nice to have a GEM reward of some sort......please.
I appreciate your time and effort in these matters and thankyou in advance
your Mate........
Hey buddy.
Clementine community manager and Clementine that you are mentioning here are two diferent people.
Clementine that you are mentioning is Ville Lyn and she have a profile by that name in this forum.
Take care buddy and i hope you get answers in all of your questions :)

[Waffleking]

Major Concern.....

you created this thread to give the appearance of making the customer happy. hoping for my friends that this is not another farce and that you really will take into account the ideas and suggestions that are presented here so that something can be done to make the legitimate concerns people have a reality in the game.

I will tell you this will make or break you gree....people have had enough....this thread could save the game and return it to prominence ....however if this is just another way for you to deflect the real problems with the game ....it could become the straw that broke the camels back.

I for one hope you really are taking this seriously

Hello Skyraiders

I am in this thread reviewing everything that is being said and taking notes. I take this thread VERY seriously and will try to address concerns as the team has time. I am already looking into fixes for the store and also have some ideas for some of the other major concerns here.

The development team does want to address these issues and again we are taking this feedback very seriously.

[Waffleking]

Something with building time and upgrade time went wrong recently. Same with upgrade cost reduction. The Sky Temple was the first building that didn't match up to calculations in my spreadsheet that have worked for every building.

That in itself isn't unprecedented. The payouts of LTB buildings changed after the Brewhouse. Payouts after that used a slightly different formula. I can tell you that this is not what's happened with the Sky Temple and after. Looking at the numbers the way they are now, I can tell you that some cost bonus calculation has gone belly up somewhere. The formula has stayed the same, but the bonuses aren't being applied correctly.

We will look into this the_bob

[Gendur]

concerns: there are no new players coming into the game, old players are leaving, after each war there are less and less guilds, and many that are existing are full of retired gamers

improvements: just an idea. What about having some achievements in the game and linked to that (or not) a global ranking of how powerful we are compared to everyone else based on many factors like level/income/stats/and so on... I know being competitive this could be a good incentive for people to keep playing

[Zepson]

I would be very happy to get my account back so that I at least can play again, contacted support several times, still no response or solution. I mean really, how long does this have to take? I'm missing out on some important things in the game :(

[SenorSwamp]

I would be very happy to get my account back so that I at least can play again, contacted support several times, still no response or solution. I mean really, how long does this have to take? I'm missing out on some important things in the game :(

Can a mod help zepson?

[Vile Lynn]

Can you relaunch the original Kingdom Age app?

[Skyraiders]

Can you relaunch the original Kingdom Age app?

this^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^+1 mill

[E-I]

Kingdom Age Prequel - before all the garbage that Grew threw in. Sign me up. :D

Only problem is who would keep playing the current version?

[SenorSwamp]

Can you relaunch the original Kingdom Age app?

I would like to nominate this as post of the year.

[Lolsies]

Updated :)

[aephlux]

I would like to see the final reward/prize for every quest in advance. Either via popups(which does not appear anymore), forum post/announcement or any other means other than finding it ourselves.

[Konan-Barbarian]

Suggestion:
I'd like to see the winner's list from the previous war. 1 second after war is over you can't review anything from that war.
Maybe there could be a history tab that would display winners. And for those that complain about bandwidth, it only loads/refreshes if you visit that tab. It would display your guild and the teams around you, but could be scrolled to the top or down to see more. The history would be available only up until the next war starts.

I find it annoying to have to visit an external forum, sometimes many days later, to find what should be in game info.

In relation to this I'd like to see a history for my guild that shows the cp and placement we did in all past wars.
I try to keep a list in my head but I keep getting buffer overflow errors and data drops out.

[Acadian]

I agree, why get rid of the prize popups but not the "buy chests or units worse than anything we have for gems when you lag popups?" And on that topic what happened to lowering cost of gem speed in crafting. Crafing is pretty much make logs that drop from boxes into either more of the same box and hope to get a different drop, or take 100 of the wood while crafting 10 at a time x 10 to get 10 of the next level to buy the next better box for a cost of about 75k heroic altogether, just to have that box drop more wood of its kind, getting annoyed, I have 3 characters crafting and its very annoying, why not just drop more of the better crates?

[Saint-BEL]

Improvement:

It would be interesting if you could make 3 sets of equipments that you can select from a dropdown menu.
depending on the situation I regularly use different equipment, for example during trials, EB and war.
But the selection menu is to timeconsuming and involves to much clicking.
Would be fun to have an easy way to change between them.

[the_bob]

Improvement:

It would be interesting if you could make 3 sets of equipments that you can select from a dropdown menu.
depending on the situation I regularly use different equipment, for example during trials, EB and war.
But the selection menu is to timeconsuming and involves to much clicking.
Would be fun to have an easy way to change between them.

Yes, I've been wanting something like this, too. For EB I certainly want my strongest attack equipment. For trials, I go with something a little lower because in my best equipment the trials cost an utterly ridiculous amount of energy to complete. I'll take the slightly weaker rewards if it means finishing the damn thing in time. Lastly, for wars I usually go with the "equip best" option and take the balanced equipment. I'd actually like to be able to put on the high attack equipment when I attack and my highest defense equipment when I'm not attacking. It would add some level of tactics to it. It's just way too time consuming as it is.

[Jnsolberg]

Please stop doing simultaneous quests that use the same energy bar, like Trials and the recent GLTQ. We had some people retire from KA due to all the back to back quests. Now it looks like there's another LTQ on the event list scheduled to start before the Raid Boss.
If you burn out your players, you will have no one left!

[E-I]

Please stop doing simultaneous quests that use the same energy bar, like Trials and the recent GLTQ. We had some people retire from KA due to all the back to back quests. Now it looks like there's another LTQ on the event list scheduled to start before the Raid Boss.
If you burn out your players, you will have no one left!

I agree. Please no over-lapping of energy quests.

And if you are going to run simultaneous GLTQs, how about one users energy (Trial quest) while the other uses stamina? We haven't had a PVP quest in ages. I enjoyed those hunt-and-destroy raid missions.

[E-I]

And here is a suggestion that may be too complicated to implement without a major rewrite, but I like it in theory more than selling back old units.

Allow players to merge units. I think the indestructible units should not merged otherwise people create some crazy strong units. But by allowing players to merge destructible units together you can actually make unit buildings relevant again.

If it were me, I would make it so that you can merge any destructible unit as long as it is in the same class (ie. Beast, infantry, etc). Either add the stats together, or use some sort of multiplication algorithm. Whatever will at least make them relevant. Also, I think that multiple units should be allowed to merge... not just two, but allow people to merge several dozen units together. For simplicity's sake, maybe it will take the name/design of the strongest merged unit? Or maybe you can create some new graphics for a few merged units. I'm sure you can figure that part out.

Anyway, I thought this would be a pretty sweet feature. But since Gree likes to implement mostly garbage, I doubt they will try. Just though I'd throw it out there anyway.

[Konan-Barbarian]

And here is a suggestion that may be too complicated to implement without a major rewrite, but I like it in theory more than selling back old units.

Since this is mentioned I thought, With selling units or buildings, at least show the amount one would get before the sale is completed. Seems last time I sold a something, I got a popup are you sure you want to sell, then found out the amount I got was less than expected and was disappointed, must have the subtraction of brokers fees.

At least

[Alisha.Banshee]

I agree that we need better guild management. Its very difficult to record everything that is guild related when it disappears as soon as you finish the quest. I spend a lot of time each month trying to record all the guild activity and weed out the non-participating players.

I would love to see the ability to send a message to all guild members at once to alert them to a deadline, the beginning of an event, or any guild related thing and it would show up on their phone's notifications like the reminders about our buildings being ready to collect, etc.

[Lolsies]

Updated. Great suggestions everyone!

[Jomama1]

Epic Boss thoughts,

While it is clear that epic boss will not return to the way it was, I think the new event needs some adjustments. The biggest challenge is that there is little one can do to improve epic boss attack yet the epic boss strength was raised. Players must feel they are getting better, but hero strength change is so small to be irrelevant and last cycle the only equipment offered was very hard to get: top 25 or top 100 indy conquest, top 1 guild conquest, rare chest drop. You did offer better equipment for cash. You will need to start feeding us better equipment so we can feel the sense of accomplishment of getting better. I would also strongly recommend including army strength as at least a small component as that always improves.

Difficulty needs to increase at a slower pace than average player ability increase or the game is pointless.

[Jomama1]

Another thought - the time requirement for this game is really reaching crazy levels - try dialing it back a bit.

[Nacon10]

No more honor payout bonus unless you add a feature where honor is relevant cause I have millions of it .

[[rudy]]

Anyone remembers the thousands of useless loot items since days gone by?

[truthteller]

And here is a suggestion that may be too complicated to implement without a major rewrite, but I like it in theory more than selling back old units.

Allow players to merge units. I think the indestructible units should not merged otherwise people create some crazy strong units. But by allowing players to merge destructible units together you can actually make unit buildings relevant again.

If it were me, I would make it so that you can merge any destructible unit as long as it is in the same class (ie. Beast, infantry, etc). Either add the stats together, or use some sort of multiplication algorithm. Whatever will at least make them relevant. Also, I think that multiple units should be allowed to merge... not just two, but allow people to merge several dozen units together. For simplicity's sake, maybe it will take the name/design of the strongest merged unit? Or maybe you can create some new graphics for a few merged units. I'm sure you can figure that part out.

Anyway, I thought this would be a pretty sweet feature. But since Gree likes to implement mostly garbage, I doubt they will try. Just though I'd throw it out there anyway.


that is a good idea
they can even follow the format of MQ (Monster Quest - RIP), and LAW (Legends at War - RIP) they use "fusion" which is basically combining 2 units to get a "better" one

it may be too complicated for them to do so, but the blue prints are there in those dead games

[truthteller]

No more honor payout bonus unless you add a feature where honor is relevant cause I have millions of it .

Nacon, long time no see my friend, did you retire from CC, KA??

also, remember long ago they did a LTQ that cost honor points, was to purchase "x" numbers of units for a prize, and the first 2 or 3 units were very cheap and the last 3 would cost you like 10m honor to get them
so having millions in honor is not a big deal if they do another "event" like that one

[Krissy]

More guild management ideas

You know the list when you press "I" that shows for each guild quest level with everyone's participation and kills then disappears. Don't make it disappear :). Please keep a cumulative list over the entire event like raid boss does. And if you had a separate list for cumulative epic boss kills too that would be fabulous. Give guild points for doing trials and track that too. A reset/zero button for guild points/donations for the founder. All of these would make my life a lot easier.

[Saint-BEL]

Updated. Great suggestions everyone!

Improvement:

It would be interesting if you could make 3 sets of equipments that you can select from a dropdown menu.
depending on the situation I regularly use different equipment, for example during trials, EB and war.
But the selection menu is to timeconsuming and involves to much clicking.
Would be fun to have an easy way to change between them.

since you seemed to have missed it :)

[Jnsolberg]

No more honor payout bonus unless you add a feature where honor is relevant cause I have millions of it .

If your guild finishes Heroic Riad Boss, you need approximatly 9000 orbs. You can buy 1 orb for 5000 Honor.

Gree, this is VERY tedious. How about adding a quantity field?

[Nacon10]

Please post war rewards earlier . War is the main event in the game and having the rewards up gets players excited .

[Jnsolberg]

We would like starting dates in the event list.
This has been asked for, for a long time.

[Nacon10]

We would like starting dates in the event list.
This has been asked for, for a long time.

this is a must. you do this in other games why not bring this feature to KA.

[Totalwar]

We would like starting dates in the event list.
This has been asked for, for a long time.

I agree be great if Gree could bring this in.

[E-I]

I agree be great if Gree could bring this in.

What is frustrating is that we have been asking for some of this stuff for nearly two years. Simple stuff, too. Like, how hard is it to post event dates? To post rewards in a timely manner? Or - gasp - to post war results before the next war starts? Many of these aren't new concepts that we have been throwing at GREE. That should be clear to anyone who has visited this forum over the last couple years.

[Jnsolberg]

What is frustrating is that we have been asking for some of this stuff for nearly two years. Simple stuff, too. Like, how hard is it to post event dates? To post rewards in a timely manner? Or - gasp - to post war results before the next war starts? Many of these aren't new concepts that we have been throwing at GREE. That should be clear to anyone who has visited this forum over the last couple years.

There is a new section in the Fourm for war results

http://forums.gree.net/forumdisplay.php?71-Kingdom-Age

Under events

[E-I]

There is a new section in the Fourm for war results

http://forums.gree.net/forumdisplay.php?71-Kingdom-Age

Under events

They only just started doing this again. After 5-6 wars where results still haven't been posted. Within 2 wars I guarantee they will "forget" to post results again. Its not like this hasn't happened before.

[JamieF]

Improvement: Stop killing the game, just take a look at this list full of bugs and concerns (http://forums.gree.net/forumdisplay.php?72-General)

GREE's feedback:
http://i59.tinypic.com/2q0svx3.jpg

[Nacon10]

i suppose gree didnt enjoy reading any feedback and stuck it to everyone with the raid boss.

[Skyraiders]

Hello Skyraiders

I am in this thread reviewing everything that is being said and taking notes. I take this thread VERY seriously and will try to address concerns as the team has time. I am already looking into fixes for the store and also have some ideas for some of the other major concerns here.

The development team does want to address these issues and again we are taking this feedback very seriously.

well givin the latest RB debacle ....i would say you need to work on your reading skills...or your comprehension skills ....your developers need to work on their coding skills...... customer service still need to work on CUSTOMER service........

i could go on and on.....but as i see it there really is no need.....if you don't believe me....just read the rest of the forum....

i do have one legitimate question.....why exactly did you start this thread again? honestly ? when you responded to my first post was that the company line you were told to trot out? i see you filled in the requests ...have you done any work in regards to all the requests here? ...sounds like my first post was spot on ...perhaps you would like to reread it....reevaluate how much is being done to help the legitimate issues in the game...and let us know

ok that was like 4 or 5 questions.....but hey you lied....so attitude reflects leadership....and i was just following in your footsteps

[Nacon10]

war rewards posted and again the indi rewards are terrible. ive had my sword for over a year and you haven't produced a stronger weapon for our heros. please introduce stronger weapons or dont increase epic boss hp. that being said if im scoring over 100k cp i should be given a better indi reward. Looks like the chests are here to stay and thats where most of the community is getting upgraded hero equip. please bring back units with bonuses for indi war reward or something better.